The libraryRecovery

Melatonin

The effect on falling asleep peaks at 4 mg taken about 3 hours before your intended bedtime.

Also called N-Acetyl-5-methoxytryptamine, 5-Methoxy-N-acetyltryptamine, Circadin, Slenyto

Sold as a dietary supplement

Who it's forAny man swallowing a gummy at lights-out and wondering why it barely works.

The item

Three squares: proven in human trials. Two: a strong signal. One: early human data. Striped: the trials disagree.

Start today

  1. Set a recurring phone alarm for three hours before bed and label it melatonin.

Why it works

It is a timing signal, not a sedative. The brain's master clock reads light from the eye and holds back its release during daylight, so it rises in darkness. Its two receptors do different jobs. One quiets firing in the clock and helps start sleep. The other shifts the clock's timing. That is why the hour you take it matters more than the size of the dose. Given each at its own best time, 0.5 mg and 3.0 mg shift the clock by a similar amount. For falling asleep, the benefit peaks at around 4 mg taken about three hours before your planned bedtime.

The doses the studies used

Study / ContextRouteDoseDuration
Review, 26 trials (PMID 38888087) - optimumOral4 mg/day, the dose with the biggest effectOne dose about 3 hours before the intended bedtime
The same review of the trials - schedule most used in clinical practiceOral2 mg/dayOne dose 30 minutes before bedtime
High-dose safety review, 79 trials, 3,861 adults over 30 (PMID 34923676)Oral10 mg or more - the threshold the review calls high doseDurations varied across the 79 trials
NCT03954899, thinking & Alzheimer's biomarkers (recruiting)Oral5 mg30 minutes before sleep, for 9 months
NCT06826755, nocturnal blood pressure in midlife women (recruiting)Oral, sustained release5 mg SR1 hour before bed, for 12 weeks
NCT04631341, cancer & CV events, ages 60-74 (not yet recruiting)Oral5 mgEvery night for one year

What people say

Here is what doctors, influencers and men online say about Melatonin, word for word.

Experts

Clinicians, authorities

  • “That is, taking melatonin just before you want to get to sleep, does help you get to sleep. The evidence on this is pretty unanimous.”

    Slate Star Codex (a psychiatrist's essay)
  • “Taking melatonin tablets adds to your body's natural supply of the hormone. This can help you get to sleep and improve the quality of your sleep.”

    NHS (UK National Health Service)
  • “There is little to no evidence that it works as a sleep aid for this purpose. It is best to see a sleep doctor who will recommend treatment for insomnia.”

    American Academy of Sleep Medicine (sleepeducation.org)

Gurus

Podcasts, channels, influencers

  • “Also, it’s worth pointing out that many people find lower doses more sedating than higher doses.”

    functional medicine blog
  • “Mice exposed to stress and took melatonin showed greater longevity and health than mice who did not take melatonin”

    biohacker podcast show notes
  • “it does not directly impact the duration of sleep, and we do not have clear evidence that it affects sleep quality under normal circumstances”

    longevity physician blog

Regular people

Forums, reviews, comments

  • “It helps me fall asleep faster, but frequent urination from 5 am wakes me up, which is not normal. Then in the morning, feeling anxious and depressed for no specific reason”

    Drugs.com user review, rated 1/10, 169 found it helpful
  • “has an average rating of 5.8 out of 10 from a total of 250 reviews on Drugs.com. 46% of reviewers reported a positive experience, while 36% reported a negative experience.”

    Drugs.com user reviews, 5.8/10 from 250 reviews
  • “It generally does help, but I can be groggy in the morning, if I took it too late in the evening. Happens sometimes.”

    Hacker News thread, top-level comment

Take 4 mg three hours before bed. The hour beats the dose.

Emergency: call 911.

I am not a doctor. This is not medical advice. This is self-education. Talk to a physician who has your history before you change anything.